Do you know Technical Analysis!?

Day

Weekly

Day

More recently, I had a theoretical controversy( discussion, debate) with one very famous and successful trader and with more than my experience.
Рассматривался дневной schedule по сахару. I will not talk about the details yet., it is interesting to listen to the opinion of traders and analysts on this issue. At all, as many people know,those analysis is not science, and the art and ability to correctly understand and anticipate the formation of patterns is quite a powerful weapon in correct positioning. Не правильно идентифицированный pattern ведет в большинстве случаев к негативному результату. I enclose three graphs. One of them shows a possible inverted Head and Shoulders pattern in red., which claims to be, in the words of my opponent, as a continuation figure. The discussion arose before,how the big negative candlestick was formed on Friday.
I would like to hear from readers whether this pattern could be considered an inverted GUI and why yes or no. Other charts can be used., if anyone knows why and say everything that was formed before Friday.